Irregular Astigmatism After LASIK & Eye Surgery: Corneal Ectasia, Transplants & Contact Lens Options

Dr. Jason Huang
·8 min read
Opens our inquiry form in a new tab. Tell us what's going on and the clinic will follow up about a consultation.

Table of Contents
Eye surgery is supposed to leave you seeing better, so it's disheartening when you end up with blur, ghosting or halos that a new pair of glasses doesn't fix. The usual culprit is irregular astigmatism: the front surface of the eye (the cornea) has been left uneven rather than smoothly curved. One of the better-known causes is corneal ectasia after LASIK, but corneal transplants, older radial keratotomy (RK) surgery and scarring can all leave the eye the same way.
This kind of blur usually can be corrected, just not with glasses. The fix is normally one of the specialty contact lenses made for irregular corneas. Here's why glasses fall short and what does work.
Regular vs. irregular astigmatism
Astigmatism means the cornea isn't evenly round. In regular astigmatism, the cornea is shaped more like the back of a spoon than a basketball, but the curve is still smooth and symmetrical. Glasses and soft toric contact lenses correct it easily, and most people with astigmatism have this kind.
In irregular astigmatism, the surface is uneven. One area might be steeper than another, or the curve might have bumps, flat spots or a bulge. Light entering different parts of your pupil gets bent by different amounts, so no single glasses prescription can line it all up. People describe the result as double or "ghost" images, starbursts around lights at night, and blur that the eye doctor can improve but never quite clear.
How eye surgery can leave the cornea irregular
LASIK and PRK
Most laser vision correction goes smoothly. When irregular astigmatism does show up afterward, it's usually from a treatment zone that ended up off-centre, uneven healing, a problem with the corneal flap (the thin layer of tissue folded back during LASIK), or ectasia.
Corneal ectasia after LASIK
Post-LASIK ectasia is when the cornea slowly thins and bulges forward after surgery. It behaves a lot like keratoconus, and it can show up months or even years later.
It's rare. A review of over 30,000 LASIK eyes(opens in new tab) found ectasia in 10 of them, an incidence of 0.033% over 8 years. A 2021 systematic review(opens in new tab) estimated 90 cases per 100,000 LASIK eyes and 20 per 100,000 PRK eyes, in people without known risk factors before surgery.
If ectasia is still progressing, the first step is usually to stop it. Corneal cross-linking uses riboflavin eye drops and ultraviolet light to stiffen the cornea. In a U.S. multicentre trial of 179 people with ectasia after refractive surgery(opens in new tab), cross-linking flattened the steepest part of the cornea and improved vision after one year, while corneas in the untreated group kept steepening.
Cross-linking stabilizes the cornea but doesn't smooth it out, so most people still need contact lenses to see clearly afterward. Our keratoconus contact lens guide goes into more detail, since the lens options are much the same.
Corneal transplants
After a corneal transplant (keratoplasty), the new tissue rarely heals into a perfectly even curve. Stitches pull on it, and the border where the graft meets your own cornea can create steep and flat zones. Surgeons can adjust or remove stitches to reduce this, but some astigmatism usually remains.
In one review of 104 eyes after full-thickness corneal transplant(opens in new tab), 17% were fitted with rigid gas permeable or scleral lenses because glasses weren't giving them satisfactory vision.
Radial keratotomy (RK)
RK was a popular nearsightedness surgery in the 1980s and 1990s. It used spoke-like cuts to flatten the cornea. Decades later, many RK patients have irregular astigmatism, vision that shifts between morning and evening, and a gradual drift toward farsightedness.
In a study of 36 eyes fitted with mini-scleral lenses after RK(opens in new tab), vision with the lenses was significantly better than with glasses, and 64% of fittings met the study's definition of success. RK corneas can be more fragile, so these fits need closer follow-up than most.
Cataract surgery
Astigmatism after cataract surgery is usually the regular kind. Glasses correct it well, and a lens implant designed to correct astigmatism (a toric implant) can reduce it during surgery.
Irregular astigmatism after cataract surgery is less common. It tends to happen when the cornea was already uneven before surgery, or when the incision healed unevenly. If your vision after cataract surgery still isn't sharp with an updated prescription, it's worth having the corneal shape checked.
Injury and infection scarring
A scratch, a deep infection or a foreign-body injury can leave a scar that changes the corneal curve. The mechanism is different from surgery, but the result is the same kind of uneven surface.
Why glasses can't fix it
A glasses lens sits about a centimetre in front of your eye and applies one correction across your whole view. That works when the cornea's error is smooth and predictable. When the surface is uneven, the error changes from one spot to the next, and a single glasses lens can't match all of them.
That's why people with irregular astigmatism often hear that their vision is "as good as it's going to get" with glasses. With glasses, that may be true. It usually isn't true with the right contact lens.
Contact lenses for irregular astigmatism
A rigid lens holds its own shape instead of taking the shape of your cornea. It gives your eye a new, smooth front surface. Tears or saline fill the gap between the lens and the uneven cornea, and your eye ends up seeing through the lens's regular curve instead of its own irregular one.
Rigid gas permeable (RGP) lenses
RGP lenses are small, firm lenses that sit on the cornea. They're often a good fit for mild to moderate irregularity and give very sharp vision. On corneas with steep bumps or a lot of scarring they can rock, move too much or feel uncomfortable at the edges.
Scleral lenses
Scleral lenses are larger rigid lenses that arch over the entire cornea without touching it and rest on the white of the eye. The space underneath is filled with saline before the lens goes in. Because the lens doesn't press on the cornea, it works well for more severe irregularity, for fragile or scarred corneas, and for people who couldn't tolerate smaller rigid lenses. Our Scleral Lenses 101 guide explains how they work day to day.
Scleral lenses have a good track record after LASIK. In a study of 18 people with irregular corneas after LASIK(opens in new tab), a large rigid lens reduced the uneven distortions behind ghosting and halos (called higher-order aberrations) by approximately 78%, to normal levels. Vision and patient-rated visual quality also improved, and the results held up after a year of wear.
Many people who've had LASIK also deal with dry eye. Scleral lenses keep the cornea bathed in fluid all day, so they can help with both problems at once. See our post on scleral lenses for severe dry eye if that sounds familiar.
Hybrid lenses
Hybrid lenses have a rigid centre for clear vision and a soft outer skirt for comfort. They're a middle-ground option for some people who want the vision of a rigid lens but find RGPs uncomfortable.
If you want a side-by-side comparison, our guide to RGP vs. soft vs. scleral lenses covers the trade-offs.
What the fitting process looks like
Post-surgical corneas vary a lot from person to person, so the fitting is more involved than for regular contacts. It usually looks like this:
-
A full eye exam to check eye health and make sure the cornea is stable. If you haven't had a recent comprehensive eye exam, that's the starting point.
-
Detailed mapping of your corneal shape (corneal topography) to see where the steep and flat areas are.
-
Trial lenses to see how the lens sits and how well you see through it.
-
Adjustments to the lens design, often over a few visits, until the vision is sharp and the lens is comfortable.
-
Training on how to put in, take out and clean the lenses. Our specialty contact lens care guide covers the routine.
After a corneal transplant or RK, we coordinate with your surgeon on timing and keep a closer eye on corneal health during follow-up visits.
If you're wondering about fees and insurance, our post on what scleral contact lenses cost in Ontario breaks it down. Many extended health plans treat lenses for irregular corneas as medically necessary.
Is it too late if your surgery was years ago?
No. Most of the people we fit for post-surgical irregular astigmatism had their surgery years or even decades earlier. What matters is how your cornea is shaped now and whether it's stable. RK patients from the 1990s, people with slowly progressing ectasia, and transplant patients who've struggled with glasses since their stitches came out can all be good candidates.
Outcomes do vary, How much your vision improves depends on the cause, how severe the irregularity is, and whether there's scarring in the centre of the cornea. Even so, many people see noticeably better with the right lens than they have since their surgery.
Talk to us about your options
If you've had LASIK, PRK, RK, a corneal transplant or cataract surgery and still have blur or ghosting that glasses haven't fixed, a contact lens fitting may help. At Elevate Vision Care in Markham, we'll map your cornea, explain what's causing the blur, and let you know whether rigid, scleral or hybrid lenses are likely to help. Submit an inquiry(opens in new tab) to book a contact lens consultation.
