Hard vs. Soft Contact Lenses: RGP, Scleral & Hybrid Compared

Dr. Jason Huang
·9 min read
Opens our online booking page in a new tab. Pick a time that suits you.

Table of Contents
Most people think of contact lenses as one thing in different prescriptions. Then soft lenses stop working, or an optometrist mentions a "hard lens" or a "scleral lens," and suddenly there are four very different designs to understand. This guide compares hard vs. soft contact lenses, including the three main types of hard lens (RGP, scleral, and hybrid), so you know what each one is for and why one might suit your eyes better than another.
A quick word on terms. "Hard lens" used to mean old-style lenses that didn't let oxygen through. Today's rigid lenses are rigid gas permeable (RGP) lenses: firm, but made of materials that let oxygen reach the eye. Scleral lenses are made from the same kind of material, just much larger. Hybrid lenses combine a rigid centre with a soft edge.
Soft Contact Lenses: The Familiar Starting Point
Soft lenses are what most people picture. They're thin, flexible, and made of water-loving plastics (hydrogel or silicone hydrogel) that drape over the clear front surface of the eye (the cornea). Most people find them comfortable within minutes.
Where they work well: Nearsightedness, farsightedness, and mild to moderate astigmatism on a regularly shaped cornea. They come as daily disposables, two-week, or monthly lenses, and they're the easiest type to put in and take out.
Where they fall short: A soft lens takes on the shape of the eye underneath it. If the cornea is irregular, as with keratoconus (a condition where the cornea thins and bulges into a cone) or after some surgeries, the lens copies the irregularity and vision stays blurry. Soft lenses also rely on your tears, so people with dry eye often find them scratchy by the afternoon.
Comfort is the big one. In a 2013 survey by Dumbleton and colleagues of more than 4,000 current and former Canadian contact lens wearers(opens in new tab), about 23% had stopped wearing lenses permanently, with discomfort and dryness as the leading reasons. If that sounds like you, our post on what to do when you can't wear soft contacts covers more options.
RGP Lenses: Sharp Optics in a Small Package
RGP lenses are small (usually a bit smaller than the coloured part of your eye) and hold their shape on the cornea. That's the whole point of them. Instead of copying the cornea's shape, the lens creates a new, smooth front surface, and your tears fill in the gaps underneath. For eyes with irregular or high astigmatism, the result is often noticeably sharper vision than any soft lens can give.
RGPs have long been the standard lens for keratoconus. In the large Collaborative Longitudinal Evaluation of Keratoconus (CLEK) Study(opens in new tab), 65% of the 1,209 patients wore RGP lenses when the study began. Our guide to keratoconus contact lenses goes into that in more detail.
They also have an eye-health upside. An Australian population-based study in Ophthalmology(opens in new tab) found that daily-wear RGP lenses had the lowest rate of serious corneal infection (microbial keratitis) of the lens types studied: 1.2 cases per 10,000 wearers a year, compared with 1.9 for daily-wear soft lenses. Both numbers are low, and good hygiene matters more than lens type, but it's a nice bonus.
Where they fall short: Comfort at the start. You'll feel an RGP lens for the first week or two while your eyelids get used to its edge. They can also pop out during contact sports and let dust get underneath, and they can be harder to keep centred on a very steep or irregular cornea.
Scleral Lenses: The Largest Rigid Lens
Scleral lenses are big: wide enough to vault completely over the cornea and rest on the white of the eye (the sclera). Before insertion, you fill the lens with sterile saline, so your cornea sits under a cushion of fluid all day.
Because they never touch the cornea, sclerals can give crisp vision on even very irregular corneas, and they're often more comfortable than people expect. That fluid layer also makes them useful for severely dry or damaged eye surfaces.
Most scleral lenses are fitted for irregular corneas. A 2020 international survey of scleral lens practitioners(opens in new tab) found that a median of 84% of their scleral fits were for corneal irregularity, 10% for ocular surface disease such as severe dry eye, and just 2% for ordinary prescriptions. Our Scleral Lenses 101 guide explains how they work day to day, and our post on scleral lenses for dry eye covers that use in depth.
Where they fall short: Handling. Putting in a large, saline-filled lens takes practice, usually with a small suction tool. Some wearers get midday fogging, where the fluid behind the lens turns cloudy and needs a rinse and refill. Fitting also takes more visits, since each lens is custom-built.
Hybrid Lenses: Rigid Centre, Soft Skirt
A hybrid lens has an RGP centre for sharp optics, surrounded by a soft outer ring that makes it feel more like a soft lens. It's about the same size as a soft lens, and it goes in and comes out much like one, which many people find easier than handling a small RGP.
Where they work well: Irregular astigmatism or mild to moderate keratoconus when an RGP gives great vision but feels uncomfortable, or when an RGP won't stay centred. They're also used by people with high regular astigmatism who want crisper vision than a soft toric lens provides.
Hybrids are fitted using corneal maps and trial lenses, like RGPs, and are usually replaced every few months because the soft skirt wears out faster than rigid material.
Where they fall short: They're usually more expensive than RGPs, and the join between the rigid and soft parts can be a weak point for tearing. They also aren't the right choice for very advanced keratoconus or severe dry eye, where scleral lenses usually do better.
Hard vs. Soft Contact Lenses: Side-by-Side Comparison
Soft | RGP | Hybrid | Scleral | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Size | Medium (covers the cornea) | Small (sits on the cornea) | Medium (rigid centre, soft edge) | Large (rests on the sclera) |
Best for | Regular corneas, standard prescriptions | Irregular or high astigmatism, early to moderate keratoconus | Irregular astigmatism when RGP comfort is a problem | Advanced irregular corneas, severe dry eye, post-surgical eyes |
Vision on irregular corneas | Limited | Very good | Very good | Very good |
Initial comfort | Immediate | Takes 1 to 2 weeks | Good | Usually good once handling is learned |
Handling | Easy | Easy to moderate | Moderate | Takes practice |
Replacement | Daily to monthly | Typically yearly | Typically every few months | Typically yearly |
Fitting | Usually one visit | One to two visits | Several visits | Several visits |
Relative cost | Lowest | Moderate | Higher | Highest |
Common Myths About Hard Contact Lenses
"Hard lenses are uncomfortable forever." RGP lenses do take some getting used to, usually a week or two of building up wear time. After that, most wearers stop noticing them. Scleral and hybrid lenses tend to feel comfortable sooner, because their edges sit on less sensitive tissue.
"Hard lenses are old technology." The old glass and PMMA lenses from decades ago didn't let oxygen through. Modern rigid lenses are made from gas permeable materials, and they're designed with corneal maps rather than a handful of standard curves. Scleral lenses in particular are no longer just a university-clinic option: in the 2020 SCOPE survey(opens in new tab), 76% of scleral lens practitioners worked in community practice.
"If soft lenses don't work, contacts aren't for me." This is the one we hear most, and it's usually wrong. Soft lenses fail for specific reasons, such as an irregular cornea, dryness, or high astigmatism, and each rigid design exists to solve one of those problems.
"Scleral lenses are the best, so I should start there." Not necessarily. For many eyes, an RGP gives excellent vision with a simpler routine and lower cost. The best lens is the one that fits your eyes, not the most advanced-sounding one.
How to Choose Between Hard and Soft Contact Lenses
This isn't a decision to make from a blog post. The right lens depends on the shape of your cornea, the health of your tear film, your prescription, and what you've already tried. Here's roughly how we think about it:
-
Healthy eyes, regular prescription, comfortable in soft lenses? Soft lenses are usually the right choice, and there's no reason to switch.
-
Soft lenses give blurry or "ghosted" vision? An irregular cornea may be the reason, and an RGP or hybrid lens is often the next step.
-
RGP vision is great but comfort isn't? A hybrid or scleral lens may give you the same clarity with less lens awareness.
-
Very irregular cornea, severe dry eye, or a history of failed lenses? Scleral lenses are usually the strongest option.
Most fittings involve trying more than one lens type. We map the cornea first with a detailed scan of its shape (called corneal topography) as part of a contact lens fitting exam(opens in new tab), then we use diagnostic lenses to see what works on your eyes.
Caring for Rigid Lenses
Rigid lenses (RGP, hybrid, and scleral) last much longer than soft lenses, so the cleaning routine matters more. They typically need a daily clean with a rigid-lens solution, regular protein removal, and, for sclerals, fresh sterile saline every time they go in. Tap water isn't safe for any contact lens, since it can carry organisms that cause serious eye infections. Our guide to specialty contact lens care and cleaning walks through each routine.
Cost and Coverage
As a rough rule, cost and fitting time go up from soft to RGP to hybrid to scleral. The rigid lenses are custom-made, and the price includes the professional fitting and follow-up visits, not just the lenses. OHIP doesn't cover contact lenses, but many extended health plans include a contact lens allowance, and some offer more when lenses are medically necessary (for example, for keratoconus). We can give you a specific estimate once we know which lens type fits your eyes.
Not Sure Which Lens Is Right for You?
If soft lenses haven't worked, or you've been told you need a "hard lens" and want to understand your options, a contact lens assessment is the place to start. We'll map your corneas, check your tear film, and let you try the lens types that make sense for your eyes before you commit. Book an eye exam(opens in new tab) to get started.
